So until next Tuesday, the only nominated flicks available on DVD that I haven't seen are Poseidon and United 93, so I naturally added them to my queue. But a few days after I did so, the reality of actually seeing all the nominated flicks started to set in and I realized that I had added United 93 to my queue. There is a very good reason as to why I didn't see that movie in theaters and that is because I was disgusted by the very idea of it. Though I was born and raised in DE, I grew up dreaming of moving to NY- I had this picture of myself living in a closet in the city, drinking coffee, smoking cigarettes, and wearing glasses while spending days locked in a room editing independent films. Though I never took up smoking and my vision still remains intact, I did develop a massive coffee addiction and got accepted to my first choice of college in Long Island. The safety of the suburbs and a jump over the bridge to the city. It was perfect. My first semester of college was the first time I'd been to NY, and I was there for less than a week when my roommate shook me awake at 9AM on a Tuesday morning (which was aggravating for me since I didn't have class until 4), and I stumbled into our common room just in time to see the second plane hit. In awe, we all hopped into the elevator to the top floor of one of Hofstra's very own towers and watched the massive buildings fall. I went home to DE that weekend and considered never returning. But I still had that dream, and it was still NYC, so I came back and embraced it. I went to school in NY for 4 years, and had a lot of wonderful times in the city, though I was haunted by nightmares of planes hitting Hofstra's dorm towers. I later realized that school in NY was enough to satisfy me, and I really belonged in LA, but I still love to go back.
So when United 93 came out, less than 5 years after 9/11, my boyfriend (a NY native) and I wrinkled our noses in disgust and swore that we wouldn't waste our time with such an atrocity.
But then the Oscar noms came out and my heart sunk when I saw United 93 in the Best Director category. I could have easily skipped over it if it was in something like Visual Effects or Costumes, but I usually like to see all the Best Director noms, and if I don't I'll eventually see them later. And it's so readily available to me through Netflix that I feel like I can't pass it up.
The Netflix arrived in the mail on Wednesday and has been sitting next to my DVD player ever since. I asked my boyfriend if he would watch it with me and he said, "No, never." Which is normally what I would say to such a thing, but....well my mission this year was very clear- all the nominated flicks I can before the Oscars.
So, what do you think I should do?? Should I, or shouldn't I, watch United 93? With all this set up, I expect some very detailed answers below 
Kanebo
Ashley Brooke
Acne Jeans
Don't do it. You already know how it ends. You can always watch all the nominated stuff next year.
1I wouldn't do it. I agree with colormesticky.
2What is it nominated for?
I respect the fact you are trying to see all the nominees before the show. It must make the show more interesting. If it was nominated for an award I didn't care as much about, I'd skip it. As said, there's always next year.
------------------------------------------------------
3Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Albert Einstein
It's nominated for Best Director and Best Editing- two of my favorite awards. I put more stock into the winner of Best Director than I do for Best Picture, and I used to picture myself accepting the Best Editing award someday, so I really am interested to see the noms for those.
I've never made it through all of the nominated films and this year won't be any different, there's just no way (unless you've got a guild pass that lets you see them for free), but I feel defeated knowing that I can see this one and won't. *Sigh*
4I feel for you, and don't know what to tell you. I've always wanted to see all the nominees (at least in categories I cared about) but I didn't ever want to see this one either.
------------------------------------------------------
5Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Albert Einstein
Having joined you on your quest, I can understand your stress over this film. And I'm not really sure what advice to give you, other than I can tell you a bit about the movie itself, since I did see it.
I actually was quite surprised that this got nominated for both Best Director and Best Editing, because there were some very serious flaws in the movie, I thought. And it seems strange to say this, but the ending, which occurs literally when the plane hits the ground, is very abrupt. But the one thing this movie isn't is exploitive. It is a film with an almost quiet sense of chaos, and it doesn't glorify anyone or play up (or down) any one person's heroism. It actually almost feels like a documentary, since (unlike in World Trade Center), it doesn't really tell any one person's story. In fact, they don't develop any of the individual characters at all, to the point where they don't even tell you who's who.
So, I guess if your concerns are whether the movie is an appropriate tribute to those who were lost, then I would say go ahead and see it. If you are more troubled by imagery from that day, then maybe skip it. There isn't anything new covered in the film and like I said, it had some "technical" problems as well.
Hope that helped some!
6Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.